Nonprofit hospitals created largely to serve the poor are including concierge doctor practices, charging sufferers annual membership charges of $2,000 or extra for simpler entry to their medical doctors.
It’s a pattern that started many years in the past with doctor practices. Hundreds of medical doctors have shifted to the concierge mannequin, through which they’ll improve their earnings whereas reducing their affected person load.
Northwestern Drugs in Chicago, Penn Drugs in Philadelphia, College Hospitals within the Cleveland space, and Baptist Well being in Miami are among the many giant hospital techniques providing concierge doctor providers. The charges, which might exceed $4,000 a yr, are along with copayments, deductibles, and different prices not paid by sufferers’ insurance coverage.
Critics of concierge medication say the follow exacerbates major care shortages, guaranteeing entry just for the prosperous, whereas driving up well being care prices. However for tax-exempt hospitals, the monetary advantages might be twofold. Concierge charges present new income immediately and function a device to assist recruit and retain physicians. These medical doctors then present profitable referrals of their well-heeled sufferers to the hospitals that make use of them.
“Hospitals are interested in physicians that provide concierge providers as a result of their sufferers don’t include dangerous money owed or a necessity for charity care, and most of them have non-public insurance coverage which pays the hospital very nicely,” mentioned Gerard Anderson, a hospital finance skilled at Johns Hopkins College.
“They’re the best affected person, from the hospitals’ perspective.”
Concierge physicians sometimes restrict their practices to a couple hundred sufferers, in contrast with a few thousand for a standard major care physician, to allow them to promise speedy entry and longer visits.
“Each time we see these fashions develop, we’re contracting the provision of major care medical doctors for the final inhabitants,” mentioned Jewel Mullen, affiliate dean for well being fairness on the College of Texas-Austin’s Dell Medical College. The previous Connecticut well being commissioner mentioned concierge medical doctors be part of giant hospital techniques due to the establishments’ reputations, whereas hospitals join concierge physicians to make sure referrals to specialists and inpatient care. “It helps hospitals safe an even bigger piece of their market,” she mentioned.
Concierge physicians sometimes promise same-day or next-day appointments. Many present sufferers their cell phone quantity.
Aaron Klein, who oversees the concierge doctor practices at Baptist Well being, mentioned this system was initially meant to serve donors.
“Excessive-end donors needed to ensure they’ve medical doctors to take care of them,” he mentioned.
Baptist opened its concierge program in 2019 and now has three practices throughout South Florida, the place sufferers pay $2,500 a yr.
“My philosophy is: It’s higher to offer world-class care to a couple hundred sufferers relatively than present insufficient care to a couple thousand sufferers,” Klein mentioned.
Concierge doctor practices began greater than 20 years in the past, primarily in upscale areas reminiscent of Boca Raton, Florida, and La Jolla, California. They catered largely to rich retirees prepared to pay further for higher doctor entry. A number of the first doctor practices to enter the enterprise have been backed by non-public fairness companies.
One of many largest, Boca Raton-based MDVIP, has greater than 1,100 physicians and greater than 390,000 sufferers. It was began in 2000, and since 2014 non-public fairness companies have owned a majority stake within the firm.
Some concierge physicians say their extra attentive care means more healthy sufferers. A research printed final yr by researchers on the College of California-Berkeley and College of Pennsylvania discovered no affect on mortality charges. What the research did discover: greater prices.
Utilizing Medicare claims information, the researchers discovered that concierge medication enrollment corresponded with a 30%-50% improve in complete well being care spending by sufferers.
For hospitals, “that is an extension of them consolidating the market,” mentioned Adam Leive, a research co-author and an assistant professor of public coverage at UC Berkeley. Inova Well being Care Providers in Fairfax, Virginia, one of many state’s largest tax-exempt hospital chains, employs 18 concierge medical doctors, who every deal with not more than 400 sufferers. These sufferers pay $2,200 a yr for the privilege.
George Salem, 70, of McLean, Virginia, has been a affected person in Inova’s concierge follow for a number of years alongside together with his spouse. Earlier this yr he slammed his finger in a resort door, he mentioned. As quickly as he received dwelling, he referred to as his doctor, who noticed him instantly and stitched up the wound. He mentioned he sees his physician about 10 to 12 instances a yr.
“I beloved my internist earlier than, however it was not possible to get to see him,” Salem mentioned. Fast entry to his physician “very a lot provides me peace of thoughts,” he mentioned.
Craig Cheifetz, a vice chairman at Inova who oversees the concierge program, mentioned the hospital system took curiosity within the mannequin after MDVIP started shifting aggressively into the Washington, D.C., suburbs a few decade in the past. At present, Inova’s program has 6,000 sufferers.
Cheifetz disputes the cost that concierge doctor packages exacerbate major care shortages. The mannequin retains medical doctors who have been contemplating retiring early within the enterprise with a lighter caseload, he mentioned. And the charges quantity to no various {dollars} a day — about what some folks spend on espresso, he mentioned.
“Inova has an unbelievable major care community for individuals who can’t afford the concierge care,” he mentioned. “We’re nonetheless offering all that’s mandatory in major care for individuals who want it.”
Some hospitals are beginning concierge doctor practices removed from their dwelling areas. For instance, Tampa Normal Hospital in Florida final yr opened a concierge follow in upper-middle-class Palm Seaside Gardens, a roughly three-hour drive from Tampa. Mount Sinai Well being System in New York runs a concierge doctor follow in West Palm Seaside.
NCH Healthcare System in Naples, Florida, employs 12 concierge physicians who deal with about 3,000 sufferers complete. “We discovered a necessity on this neighborhood for individuals who needed a extra personalised well being care expertise,” mentioned James Brinkert, regional administrator for the system. Members pay an annual payment of at the least $3,500.
NCH sufferers whose medical doctors convert to concierge and who don’t wish to pay the membership payment are referred to different major care practices or to pressing care, Brinkert mentioned.
KFF Well being Information is a nationwide newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about well being points and is without doubt one of the core working packages at KFF—an unbiased supply of well being coverage analysis, polling, and journalism. Study extra about KFF.
Subscribe to KFF Well being Information’ free Morning Briefing.
Marketing campaign Motion